The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[Punchy]

I liked this, this new world is ripe with storytelling possibilities, and there's lots of mysteries set up. I particularly liked the take on the Spirit, I'll be checking out that ongoing for sure, and probably Doc Savage too.

[doombug]

Deserves a revenge 0, IMO.

seeing how i gave his book at least a 5 he better not pull that shit.

[Punchy]

Review based on the comic, not on percieved personal slights.

[doombug]

I'm going to be grading all books on a curve based on the average score of X-Men Forever #18 from now on. So if I would have given a book a 7, it will be 7 * .549, giving it an actual score of 3.843. This is based on the fact that X-Men Forever is the most perfect comic of all time, and therefore represents the highest possible grade on the scale.

can we vote to kick jude out for this confusing bullshit?

[doombug]

Review based on the comic, not on percieved personal slights.

i'd hope does.

[Old Man]

Spicy Dick, John Sunlight was in this issue, he was the guy with the beard drinking Vodka on the bench.

John Sunlight = Odin?

[Old Man]

I'm going to be grading all books on a curve based on the average score of X-Men Forever #18 from now on. So if I would have given a book a 7, it will be 7 * .549, giving it an actual score of 3.843. This is based on the fact that X-Men Forever is the most perfect comic of all time, and therefore represents the highest possible grade on the scale.

You needs meds.

[S.F. Jude Terror]

Review based on the comic, not on percieved personal slights.

Oh thanks for that.

[Punchy]

:lol:

Oh thanks for that.

Why is this funny? When have I ever rated a comic badly out of spite?

[Starlord]

Why is this funny? When have I ever rated a comic badly out of spite?

Not that I can remember. You just refuse to review books out of spite.

[doombug]

Not that I can remember. You just refuse to review books out of spite.

he read that issue too!

[Punchy]

Not that I can remember. You just refuse to review books out of spite.

My refusal to review Teen Titans and X-Men Forever was not done of spite, but out of love, I refuse to lower your averages!

[Starlord]

My refusal to review Teen Titans and X-Men Forever was not done of spite, but out of love, I refuse to lower your averages!

So you didn't join your friends in reading books that you felt you wouldn't care for because you love us?

[Punchy]

So you didn't join your friends in reading books that you felt you wouldn't care for because you love us?

You'd have been more pissed off if I did review it and slated it.

[S.F. Jude Terror]

You'd have been more pissed off if I did review it and slated it.

I'm not actually pissed off about anyone who read the book and gave it a bad review. I'm more pissed off that people, even people who hadn't read an XMF comic, already decided they hated it before reading it, and either refused to give it a try or allowed their bias to cloud their review. If you don't like something, you don't like it. But I thought the purpose of this was to try books you wouldn't normally read with an open mind. XMF is the first book in a long time in here that I was reading anyway, and didn't get specifically for the group.