Amoebas wrote::lol: If I know you at all, you probably went into this book not wanting to like anything in it. Execpt for the quotes you most likely had your entire critique written long before you actually saw the issue. I suspect this because I'd probably do the same for a Bendis book if I were to review one (which I won't because I'm aware of my bias).
I went into this issue knowing it would be a clusterfuck from the spoilers. I've said many times I hate resurection, I hate hokey silver age type plots, and bad dialogue really gets to me, so of course I gave this issue a bad review.
Also, I don't care if "that's how guardians speak" the dialogue itself was cringeworthy, absolutely horriific. Try imaginining someone saying that outloud.