The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[******]

Moore's last issue was #64. #87 was Rick Veitch's last issue.

I meant "in 87" as in 1987.

[Daringd]

Brightest Day #23
NO!

0/10

[Starlord]

Wow Doombug... you too! I thank you for reviewing it but that was harsh! A 7? That's practically a 0 on an epic scale. Just thought you were cooler than that. No problem though, it's a Marvel world and I'm the lone Superman.

But remember this my friend; NEVER come to me on the day of my daughter's wedding and ask me for a favor.

[doombug]

Is that a Punchy 7 or a regular 7? The scaling here is very important.

It's a regular 7, meaning I think it's an average book.

[doombug]

Considering that both HB and DC are owned by sprawling conglomerate Time-Warner (paging Nacireman! ), I don't think HB will sue.

Which is probably why DC feels comfortable doing this.

"Captain DC's
NOT a hero!
Gonna take comic sales down to zero!"

The Hannah Barbara rights are owned by Ted Turner and TBS/Cartoon Network. Not WB to my knowledge.

[Punchy]

Starlord, stop attempting to guilt people into giving this a high score, let people think what they want.

[******]

It's a regular 7, meaning I think it's an average book.

Hard to imagine why I'd ask.

i don't want to write a review because I read and I strongly disliked it.

[3MJ]

How can you strongly dislike something and give it.. 7 out of 10.

[doombug]

How can you strongly dislike something and give it.. 7 out of 10.

i didn't know my review was going to be studied like the goddamn zapruder film (that how you spell that?)

the art was good, story was average. it gets a 7.

why the fuck does it matter to you twigg it's my review.

[3MJ]

Well I'm just wondering how if you strongly dislike something you can give it a 7 out of 10.

[******]

If strong dislike is a 7 then I'm left with no other conclusion than that Doombug is actually Punchy's most elaborate performance art prank ever. Congratulations on maintaining this illusion for as long as you have Niam, well played.

[doombug]

...I just fucking wrote why!

Why are you intentionally trying to piss me off today? The book is an average book. Just because I disliked it doesn't mean it's not an average book.

Is your reading comprehension at a 4 year olds level?


And Punchy it's pretty damn obvious that Star is fucking around.

[******]

I just don't want to hurt a Star week.

[3MJ]

I think it's a contradiction to give a book a 7, and then say you strongly disliked it.

I just want the Review Group to be fair.

[******]

I think it's a contradiction to give a book a 7, and then say you strongly disliked it.

I just want the Review Group to be fair.

If everyone scored on the Punchy scale, we wouldn't have this problem.