The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[BlueStreak]

Moving forward in this thread, let's tone down the namecalling, shall we?

If you want to discuss the merits of Coopcap's book, great. However, any further namecalling will not be tolerated.

[Royal Nonesuch]

I'm not all the way through the story yet, but so far I agree with all of Jude's critiques, but I would add this: spelling counts!

[shannonh]

So by your Logic, every effin artist like Walt Simonson drawing THOR is just a fanboy because he isn't Jack Kirby? So all the great stories that Frank Miller did, including Batman is just a fan boy?

These two examples took the books and the characters to new heights, not to mention we have decent movies finally because of Miller. (OK, NO ONE MENTION THE SPIRIT MOVIE!)

is that what you are saying?

Ummmm, no.

You did NOT get hired by Marvel to do this so PLEASE dont compare yourself to the likenesses of SIMONSON and MILLER.

You could have easily tweaked this story, took the Marvel characters out of the equation, and had your very own "INDIE" comic but instead.......you did what you did . I hope my comment is more clear to you now.

[syxxpakk]

Read it. Didn't like it.

[COOPCAP]

Who says I wasn't a professional?

Why do you guys look down on Indies? hell there are guys in the biz that suck.
besides Simonson's Thor was done in highschool by Simonson then tweaked when he finally got the chance.

Ummmm, no.

You did NOT get hired by Marvel to do this so PLEASE dont compare yourself to the likenesses of SIMONSON and MILLER.

You could have easily tweaked this story, took the Marvel characters out of the equation, and had your very own "INDIE" comic but instead.......you did what you did . I hope my comment is more clear to you now.

[COOPCAP]

Read it. Didn't like it.

Thank You and that is your right and I respect that right. what did you not like?

[syxxpakk]

The lettering has already been talked about, so I won't bother with that. The art was pretty bad, IMO. Story left a lot to be desired. It was pretty groan-inducing.

[COOPCAP]

The lettering has already been talked about, so I won't bother with that. The art was pretty bad, IMO. Story left a lot to be desired. It was pretty groan-inducing.

well, ok......enjoy your wrestling.

[shannonh]

Dude, it's not INDY....That's all I'm saying.

I love INDY....That's not what you did. Fandom is not INDY....You did not do INDY. INDY is.......You know what.....never mind. You are so INDY, you need a tan hat and a bull whip.



Indy is awesome.

[COOPCAP]

Dude, it's not INDY....That's all I'm saying.

I love INDY....That's not what you did. Fandom is not INDY....You did not do INDY. INDY is.......You know what.....never mind. You are so INDY, you need a tan hat and a bull whip.



Indy is awesome.

[syxxpakk]

well, ok......enjoy your wrestling.

I will.

[S.F. Jude Terror]

This thread is weird.

[xaraan]

No more than the picture of Superman you are using.

As long as I am not making money on their character Marvel can't do anything.

And if we really want to talk about copyrights maybe Marvel should give the Capt. America rights back to Simon & Kirby.

And the rights to all the Marvel Characters Jack created.
I think it's a crime. Funny, there are no Superheroes to help.

This is not actually true. Granted Marvel probably won't do anything b/c it's just fanfic, but they actually could if they wanted to. I've had a lot of my work pulled from places using my photography work even though it was fan created stuff and wasn't for profit or similar.



Although why is captain america knocking down the buildings on the cover?? that seems like an odd thing for him to do..

[Apache Chef]

This thread is weird.

Summary:

COOPCAP: Hey guys, check out my work. Hey guys, check out my work. Hey guys, check out my work

OUTHOUSERS: I don't like it.

COOPCAP: Ok, then fuck you!

OUTHOUSERS: No, fuck YOU!

COOPCAP:

"No, fuck YOU!"

[J.M. Hunter]

I thought this was a thread about the real Captain America? The Black one?