The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

by **LOLtron** » Tue Sep 20, 2011 10:23 pm

Glee returns for its 3rd season. See what The Outhouse's resident Gleek, Erik Galston has to say about the episode.

After a mediocre second season, Glee returned to former glory in the season 3 opener. Instead of focusing on just a couple characters, every character got some spotlight in the opener. Ryan Murphy promised a return to basics, and it really was. With only 5 musical numbers, the emphasis seemed to back to the story and the characters.

The episode started by having Jacob go around asking everyone what there future plans were, with this the audience finds out who among the glee club are seniors and who are juniors, Tina and Artie are juniors while the rest are seniors. Mercedes revealed that Sam moved away after his father got a job in another city, and that she was now dating a new guy. Rachel and Kurt plan to go to New York for college, and Finn has no clue what he's doing. During the first glee club meeting, we find out that Lauren quit Glee club after the nationals loss, and Quinn has not been heard from since. Shortly after Quinn walks down the hall with pink hair, nose piercings and a new attitude, and a new set of friends, the "skanks." Sue announces not only that she's running for congress on a platform of cutting the arts, but she also makes Santana and Becky co-captains of the Cheerios.

Santana tries to recruit Quinn to come back to the Cheerios, but Quinn declines. Rachel then talks to Quinn about rejoining New Directions. Quinn declines Rachel's offer as well, but seems to have second thoughts about her decision.

In order to recruit new members for New Directions, Will tells the club that there will be purple pianos randomly placed around the school, and when the club finds them, they need to perform a song in front of who ever is there. To counter that Sue tells Santana she needs to destroy all the pianos and make it look like an accident.

During lunch, a purple piano is in the cafeteria, so after Rachel rallies the club, the group performs the Go-Go's "We Got The Beat." After the performance, Becky slushies Rachel, which causes a mass food fight. Defeated the group goes back to the choir room, where a potential recruit comes in. Sugar Motta, the daughter of the man who donated the purple pianos, auditions. Sugar, after saying she was better than everyone else, can't sing. This leads Will to wonder if he needs to be a little tougher.

Rachel and Kurt are told about a school in New York that is holding mixers in the area. They prepare what they think is a great number, only to arrive at the mixer and get embarrassed by how talented the other students are. Both Rachel and Kurt vow to make sure the other person gets into the school.

Blaine, who transferred to McKinley, auditions for the club by performing, Tom Jone's "Its Not Unusual" with the Cheerios. The song ends with the Cheerios putting lighter fluid all over the piano. Quinn happens to flick her cigarette bud, and it sets the piano on fire.

After the events outside, Will welcomes Blaine into the club, while banning Santana from the club for being the cause of the fire, and siding with Sue. Rachel announces that the musical should be West Side Story so she can play Maria, which Mercedes demands open auditions. Kurt declares he's running for senior class president. The show ends with the group singing "You Can't Stop the Beat," while Quinn looks on from the rafters.

I really enjoyed the season premiere of Glee. The characters really reminded me of how they were in the first season. I'm also really digging the "new" Quinn. One of the things that really has me looking forward to this season, is the amount of "outside" writers that are being brought in. Just looking at the credits Marti Noxon from Buffy and Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa (comic fans will recognize him from his work for Marvel Comics) were brought in among others.

Fans of the Glee Project will recognize on of the two runners up from that show Lindsay Pierce as the featured soloist at the mixer.

I'm completely optimistic that this season of Glee will be better than the previous one. Just judging from the clips for next episode it seems to be.

Written or Contributed by: Erik Galston

http://173.199.169.70/index.php/reviews/entertainment-reviews/16105-gleeview-the-purple-piano-project.html/

by **Thor-El** » Tue Sep 20, 2011 10:39 pm

Excellent review Erik!

I really enjoyed this episode, it did have a few of the things that I find dumb about the show, but overall it was very entertaining.

by **Starlord** » Tue Sep 20, 2011 11:17 pm

Great review! I'm having more and more of an issue with Sue. I really love that actress but I just can't get past the fact that she can damage school property in front of people and get away with this crap.

by **e_galston** » Tue Sep 20, 2011 11:47 pm

technically it wasn't even school property, i think if i remember correctly Will said it was private property she destroyed..

by **rdrsfn82** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 2:35 am

This episode had some really really really dumb shit.

Sue could not go on the news and promote her campaign like that. They would have to give equal time to every other candidate.

Will tossing the glitter was just typical bullying crap and everything he's always claimed to be against. Similarly Becky throwing the slushie to start the food fight was out of character, and she was overall pretty mean in this episode which is against the good hearted character she's been all along. If this is addressed later in the season with Sue realizing she's corrupting such a good person, cool, if not then I have an issue with it.

Sam leaving sucks and I wish that didn't have to happen. In fact, it didn't have to happen, but whatever.

That new girl that tried out and was rejected better not be a long term character, because she was just terrible and annoying.

Blaine has no parents, and everything involving him in this episode was dumb. No way his parents would let him leave a great private school for this school. And if Kurt cares about him so much, why didn't he bring him to the thing with Rachel so he could try to go to NYC as well? That made no fucking sense at all.

The show still has some entertaining things, next week looks like it might be fun, I enjoyed the music, there are times I enjoy certain characters, some of them seem to be moving forward (though we've seen that before and seen all that progress ignored the next week), but there's still a lot of glaring holes on the show that are just irritating.

by **e_galston** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 12:10 pm

One thing i will say about last night, it was nice to have music that isn't currently on the radio. 3 songs were broadway/musical, one being tom jones, and the other an 80s song. It doesn't get much non-modern than that. It was very refreshing..

by **Starlord** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 12:12 pm

e_galston wrote:One thing i will say about last night, it was nice to have music that isn't currently on the radio. 3 songs were broadway/musical, one being tom jones, and the other an 80s song. It doesn't get much non-modern than that. It was very refreshing..

The music was awesome and the dance numbers were great too. I've never had a problem with that part of the show. But my mind just can't wrap itself around a school where the kids are constantly being assaulted with slushies and the police or anyone have been called in to stop it.

by **rdrsfn82** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 2:28 pm

e_galston wrote:One thing i will say about last night, it was nice to have music that isn't currently on the radio. 3 songs were broadway/musical, one being tom jones, and the other an 80s song. It doesn't get much non-modern than that. It was very refreshing..

I enjoyed all the songs last night as well.

by **rdrsfn82** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 2:29 pm

Starlord wrote:
The music was awesome and the dance numbers were great too. I've never had a problem with that part of the show. But my mind just can't wrap itself around a school where the kids are constantly being assaulted with slushies and the police or anyone have been called in to stop it.

And apparently you can't suspend or expel kids for doing that stuff. :smt011

by **e_galston** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 2:38 pm

what i mean with the music, is a lot of the criticism on here about last season outside of the plot problems, was that most of the songs were 'modern' songs and people here didn't seem to like that.

by **rdrsfn82** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 2:46 pm

e_galston wrote:what i mean with the music, is a lot of the criticism on here about last season outside of the plot problems, was that most of the songs were 'modern' songs and people here didn't seem to like that.

I am not a fan of most of the modern music they were doing, so this was a nice job of picking songs that were more fun.

Blaine doing the Carlton dance was great.

by **Kolimar** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 4:41 pm

Excellent review.

by **Thor-El** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 9:58 pm

e_galston wrote:One thing i will say about last night, it was nice to have music that isn't currently on the radio. 3 songs were broadway/musical, one being tom jones, and the other an 80s song. It doesn't get much non-modern than that. It was very refreshing..

Agreed, I love it much more when they do older songs and not stuff that I can hear on any station right now.

by **Thor-El** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 9:59 pm

rdrsfn82 wrote:
I am not a fan of most of the modern music they were doing, so this was a nice job of picking songs that were more fun.

Blaine doing the Carlton dance was great.

Anyone doing the Carlton Dance is always awesome!

by **~Alima~** » Wed Sep 21, 2011 10:11 pm

Great Review!

I'm still processing it, but the things that bugged me were the destruction of the pianos and Sam. Other than that, I love the numbers and the potential growth with Rachel and Kurt competing with those mixer kids.