The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

by **CausticLibrarian** » Fri Sep 23, 2011 5:04 pm

I want to see the shitty scores that Suicide Squad will be getting

by **BlueStreak** » Sun Sep 25, 2011 9:13 pm

Updated with new scores.

by **guitarsmashley** » Mon Sep 26, 2011 5:25 pm

So are the other people with assignments going to be reviewing their books?

by **Amoebas** » Mon Sep 26, 2011 6:27 pm

As of the 09/25 update (by Average)

100 - Batwoman
89.0 - Animal Man
85.0 - Demon Knights
85.0 - Frankenstein, Agent of SHADE
84.7 - Swamp Thing
83.0 - Superboy
83.0 - Batwing
81.8 - Action Comics
81.3 - Green Lantern
81.0 - Resurrection Man
80.3 - Batgirl
77.5 - Men of War
77.4 - Justice League International
73.8 - Justice League
73.0 - Mister Terrific
72.5 - OMAC
71.7 - Static Shock
70.7 - Stormwatch
70.0 - Legion Lost
69.0 - Grifter
68.7 - Green Arrow
68.7 - Suicide Squad
62.0 - Hawk and Dove
60.5 - Deathstroke
48.0 - Batman and Robin
48.0 - Red Lantern

by **Mammon, Fool Breaker** » Wed Sep 28, 2011 12:52 pm

68.7 - Green Arrow
68.7 - Suicide Squad

^ Thats a typo, S.S. should be at 66.6 it has 200pts, not 206.

by **avengingtitan** » Thu Sep 29, 2011 4:34 am

I wouldnt be surprised if Blackhawks and I Vampire were the lowest rated overall. As bad as Hawk and Dove was at least it told a story that made sense.

by **BlueStreak** » Thu Sep 29, 2011 1:11 pm

avengingtitan wrote:I wouldnt be surprised if Blackhawks and I Vampire were the lowest rated overall. As bad as Hawk and Dove was at least it told a story that made sense.

Considering I, Vampire has been getting universal praise from most sites, I sincerely doubt it.

by **BlueStreak** » Thu Sep 29, 2011 2:28 pm

And bump as it's now updated.

by **Flynn the Pirate** » Thu Sep 29, 2011 3:36 pm

avengingtitan wrote:I wouldnt be surprised if Blackhawks and I Vampire were the lowest rated overall. As bad as Hawk and Dove was at least it told a story that made sense.

I actually thought I, Vampire was quite good.

by **alaska1125** » Thu Sep 29, 2011 11:49 pm

BlueStreak wrote:
Considering I, Vampire has been getting universal praise from most sites, I sincerely doubt it.

Somebody review this book ASAP. I thought it was one of the best of the 52. Top ten. And this one was at the very bottom of my list initially.

by **guitarsmashley** » Mon Oct 03, 2011 2:57 pm

I wonder where the catwoman reviews are? :groucho:

by **BlueStreak** » Wed Oct 05, 2011 4:54 pm

Preview of the list that will go up tonight.

1: Animal Man (Review) - 361 (Four Reviews In, Average Score: 90.25)

2: Batwing (Review) - 332 (Four Reviews In, Average Score: 83.0)

3: Justice League International (Review) - 332 (Four Reviews + Two Bonus Reviews, Average Score: 77.4)

4: Action Comics (Review) - 327 (Four Reviews In, Average Score: 81.75)

5: Batgirl (Review) - 312 (Four Reviews In, Average Score: 80.25)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6: Batman (Review) - 287 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 95.67)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7: Justice League (Review) - 283 (Four Reviews + Two Bonus Reviews, Average Score: 73.8 )

8: Grifter (Review) - 276 (Four Reviews, Average Score: 69)

9: Stormwatch (Review) - 268 (Four Reviews In, Average Score: 67.0)

10: Suicide Squad (Review) - 267 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 68.67)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

11: Swamp Thing (Review) - 254 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 84.67)

12: Superboy (Review) - 249 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 83.0)

13: Green Lantern Corps (Review) - 246 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 82)

14: Green Lantern (Review) - 244 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 81.33)

15: Wonder Woman (Review) - 243 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 81.0)

16: Justice League Dark (Review) - 238 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 79.33)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

17: Catwoman (Review) - 236 (Four Reviews In, Average Score: 59.0)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

18: Mister Terrific (Review) - 219 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 73)

19: Static Shock (Review) - 215 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 71.67)

20: Voodoo (Review) - 210 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 70.0)

21: Detective Comics (Review) - 207 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 69)

22: Green Arrow (Review) - 206 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 68.67)

23: Men of War (Review) - 205 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 68.33)

24: Fury of Firestorm (Review) - 205 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 68.33)

25: Aquaman (Review) - 199 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 66.33)

26: Deathstroke (Review) - 193 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 64.33)

27: Nightwing (Review) - 193 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 96.5)

28: Batwoman (Review) - 190 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 95.0)

29: OMAC (Review) - 178 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 59.33)

30: Superman: Man of Tomorrow (Review) - 173 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 57.67)

31: Green Lantern: New Guardians (Review) - 165 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 82.5)

32: Birds of Prey (Review) - 159 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 79.5)

33: Savage Hawkman (Review) - 158 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 79)

34: Hawk and Dove (Review) - 142 (Three Reviews In, Average Score: 47.33)

35: Teen Titans (Review) - 141 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 70.5)

36: DC Universe Presents (Review) - 122 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 61.0)

37: Legion of Superheroes (Review) - 101 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 50.5)

38: Red Lanterns (Review) - 96 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 48)

39: Red Hood and the Outlaws (Review) - 96 (Two Reviews In, Average Score: 48)

40: Blue Beetle (Review) - 86 (One Review In)

41: Demon Knights (Review) - 85 (One Review In)

42: Frankenstein, Agent of SHADE (Review): 85 (One Review In)

43: Resurrection Man (Review) - 81 (One Review In)

44: Supergirl (Review) - 81 (One Review In)

45: All-Star Western (Review) - 81 (One Review In)

46: Captain Atom (Review) - 71 (One Review In)

47: Legion Lost (Review) - 70 (One Review In)

48: Batman and Robin (Review) - 48 (One Review In)

by **guitarsmashley** » Thu Oct 06, 2011 3:06 pm

guitarsmashley wrote:So are the other people with assignments going to be reviewing their books?

This. Do books have more than one reviewer like Batman and Robin since someone else could raise the score I gave it.

by **BlueStreak** » Thu Oct 06, 2011 3:14 pm

guitarsmashley wrote:
This. Do books have more than one reviewer like Batman and Robin since someone else could raise the score I gave it.

Deadline's not until October 15th. All books have four reviewers.

by **Eli Katz** » Thu Oct 06, 2011 3:27 pm

The average score should be used to determine rank, not the cumulative points a book receives. Wouldn't that make more sense? (In case you don't get all four reviews.)

Also, why aren't RG scores factored into the calculation?