The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[ThatGuyRoman]

This is one of, if not the, best X-Men book right now.

I think it might be the sole champion. I enjoy (almost) all the X-books right now, but none do I look forward to more than this one. (It's slowly replaced X-Force in my heart.)

[Chris]

This book sucks donkey nuts. Every damn' issue has to do about space. The students are a not even a priority in storytelling. Let me guess, this issue had some space-related segment to it, didn't it?

This is a very ill-informed post.

[Agent Panic]

This is a very ill-informed post.

Not really.

The Bachalo art was whack. He drew better in Generation X.

Beast & Co.'s Fantastic Voyage for Kitty's alien abortion, Quentin and Wolverine gambling in fucking space, a Brood attack on the school, and focusing on the two alien members of a whole school of mutants is all ridiculous.

The mutant students on Earth would have enough to worry about on Earth, without all the intergalactic bullshit they force into this book. I don't like the direction this book is going, it's not really that great and to say it's the best X-men book out NOW isn't really saying much, is it?

Besides, X-Factor is better than this. Hell, even the current Astonishing X-men is better than this.

[dairydead]

Not really.

The Bachalo art was whack. He drew better in Generation X.

Beast & Co.'s Fantastic Voyage for Kitty's alien abortion, Quentin and Wolverine gambling in fucking space, a Brood attack on the school, and focusing on the two alien members of a whole school of mutants is all ridiculous.

The mutant students on Earth would have enough to worry about on Earth, without all the intergalactic bullshit they force into this book. I don't like the direction this book is going, it's not really that great and to say it's the best X-men book out NOW isn't really saying much, is it?

Besides, X-Factor is better than this. Hell, even the current Astonishing X-men is better than this.

It's one of my favorite runs on any X-book ive ever read.

[oogy]

It's one of my favorite runs on any X-book ive ever read.

Quit being such a Buddy-Bear!

[ThatGuyRoman]

I will agree that Bachalo 16 years ago drew WAY better than Bachalo now ... but other than that ...

[Agent Panic]

It's one of my favorite runs on any X-book ive ever read.

My condolences.

[guitarsmashley]

Bachalo is stylized amazingness, but Bradshaw has a great style like Art Adams.

[BubbaKanoosh]

Bradshaw is trying to BE Art Adams, not a style like his.

[guitarsmashley]

Bradshaw is trying to BE Art Adams, not a style like his.

And I love Art Adams, so I'm ok with it.

My condolences.

you're also the person that suggested Girls to anyone over Ultra...and well Girls is awful. You're opinion on anything other than nose picking fingers are null in void.

[Agent Panic]

you're also the person that suggested Girls to anyone over Ultra...and well Girls is awful. You're opinion on anything other than nose picking fingers are null in void.

Girls is, simply put, a better story and it was made with more of an effort. Ultra, while good, was just a character piece, The Luna Brothers upped their game with Girls, as it become more plot driven but certainly kept a great sense of characterization with a decent sized cast, as well as touching upon interesting abstractions. It was ambitious and it worked.

And anyway, why are you attempting to be insulting in your comment? I didn't insult anyone. It's feeble.

[guitarsmashley]

Girls is, simply put, a better story and it was made with more of an effort. Ultra, while good, was just a character piece, The Luna Brothers upped their game with Girls, as it become more plot driven but certainly kept a great sense of characterization with a decent sized cast, as well as touching upon interesting abstractions. It was ambitious and it worked.

And anyway, why are you attempting to be insulting in your comment? I didn't insult anyone. It's feeble.

you don't get how this works do you?

But Girls will still be awful.

[doombug]

Bachalo is stylized amazingness, but Bradshaw has a great style like Art Adams.

as usual, I agree with Yoni.

[Chris]

I really, really dislike Bradshaw's art.

[guitarsmashley]

I really, really dislike Bradshaw's art.

Well your very wrong too but you love Essex County so I can forgive you.