I didn't like it much, but I am in the minority.
it, but its the same as my concerns with him doing Star Wars, it didn't feel
like Star Trek to me. Yes it was good, it had all the right pieces, but it was done in such a way that it felt like something completely other than a Star Trek movie. But that is kinda what they were going for with that, so in that sense it was a complete success.
I'm just not sure what his or Kathleen Kennedy's vision or direction are right now for Star Wars.
Despite all the faults of the prequels, i.e. the bad acting, crappy characters, and shitty plots, it still felt like Star Wars to me. It was still a return to what I knew and loved.