God, I'm far to drunk to argue right now.
Anyway, PAD is probably the most consistently writer in the business right now. Even the stuff of his I don't enjoy, like most of She Hulk, the Quicksilver one-shot, and the Stroman arc of XFactor, is a good deal better than a lot of comics out right now.
Do I agree with him sicking Marvel's legal team on that web site? Hell no, I think he's probably keeping people from reading the comic who would have otherwise. But that doesn't make the book any less awesome, and it doesn't make him any worse as a writer.
I guess it doesn't matter, though. We're all going to overreact to shit because we're on a message board and that's what we do.