*Membership spots not really limited!
Fair point. Still.. these people are snipers with handguns. The easy headshots are pretty laughable.
Also, they outnumbered the guy on the tower.. there was one guy shooting at Maggie/Carol/Carl/Beth.. and they all had rifles -- with scopes -- and a gun for Carl shooting back.
Carl was the only one shooting with a gun that wasn't firing a burst with every shot which would lower accuracy and I am pretty sure Carl would have been damn close to out of range at that angle.