The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[Doc Jon]

the goal of every season is to win the superbowl.

if eli wins two superbowls, he has led his team to more than peyton

and thus completed his goal more than Peyton

he is thus better than peyton

plus, he doesn't have a 90 yr old man's neck and has more chances! he may even become triple the guy peyton was!

That's not what you said at all...

Hostetler has more SB rings than Dan Marino.

So Hostetler is better than Dan Marino.

You attempted to establish a direct correlation between number of Superbowl wins and quality of the QB, even with the aside regarding Eli being 3 times the man Peyton is.

C'mon now, councilor...

[goof]

If Tampa gets Marty Schottenheimer as a head coach maybe he'll push for them to get Peyton, kind of like he did with Joe Montana and K.C..

[CountD]

Of course they do, because that's the only way you can claim your argument.

Hey, you want to believe that Eli is the better QB? That's cool. Present something more convincing.

he's reached the superbowl quicker than Eli. that's reason #2. see my previous post.

my jury is still out on who's better- see my entire body of work post.

[kingbeavis]

As a chiefs fan, I hope he lands in KC. They are WAY under the cap, and I can't stand Matt Cassel.

[CountD]

As a chiefs fan, I hope he lands in KC. They are WAY under the cap, and I can't stand Matt Cassel.

I probably should've included the Chiefs as a poll option. my bad and good luck!

[eltopo]

the Kansas city Royales

[CountD]

the Kansas city Royales

should be a minor league team

[Doc Jon]

he's reached the superbowl quicker than Eli. that's reason #2. see my previous post.

my jury is still out on who's better- see my entire body of work post.

I have less of a problem with your argument.

The jury is most certainly still out.

[CountD]

I have less of a problem with your argument.

The jury is most certainly still out.

I say that as a true-blue Giants fan, too.

But your envious green Eagles heart cannot deny Eli is playing at an elite level right now. I think he's top 5 among active QBs. I have them at
Brady
Brees
Rogers
Rothlesberger
Eli

[guitarsmashley]

One of the more interesting places he could end up that you left out? Seattle.

[CountD]

One of the more interesting places he could end up that you left out? Seattle.

yeah, you're right. I put this together hastily.

and Seattle seems pretty good as a team.

[Doc Jon]

I say that as a true-blue Giants fan, too.

But your envious green Eagles heart cannot deny Eli is playing at an elite level right now. I think he's top 5 among active QBs. I have them at
Brady
Brees
Rogers
Rothlesberger
Eli

I don't know. The season was most definitely up and down.

And that game against the Niners came down to special teams, not Eli. I'm really not trying to take anything away from Eli, but without those 2 plays by the special teams, we're not having this discussion at all...

[guitarsmashley]

I say that as a true-blue Giants fan, too.

But your envious green Eagles heart cannot deny Eli is playing at an elite level right now. I think he's top 5 among active QBs. I have them at
Brady
Brees
Rogers
Rothlesberger
Eli

Brady
Brees
Rodgers
Eli

drop off.

[eltopo]

I don't know. The season was most definitely up and down.

And that game against the Niners came down to special teams, not Eli. I'm really not trying to take anything away from Eli, but without those 2 plays by the special teams, we're not having this discussion at all...

I don't know about that Eli made a lot of third down and long conversions against a defense that was beating the shit out of him

[CountD]

interesting.