The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[Punchy]

You slacked away your chance at determining the rules a couple of years ago. I'm not changing them.

I think you should, it's not fair on others who actually do get involved.

[Kerny]

CBR giveth, and CBR taketh away.

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page ... e&id=25622

I'd say his reasoning is pretty thin.

Tabu doesn't make any sense.

And he totally read the Imhotep/Horus/Set thing wrong.

[Victorian Squid]

1) That photo is about 4 years old

2) Knock off the personal attacks and stay off my Facebook

3) It's better when you're not here.

You're just pathetic, end of story.

[Punchy]

You're just pathetic, end of story.

You're the pathetic one, your superiority complex is incredible for such a petty troll.

[thefourthman]

CBR giveth, and CBR taketh away.

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page ... e&id=25622

I'd say his reasoning is pretty thin.

That's Tabu, that's not a review. He is a known comic hater.

Plus reading his "review" it is clear he had no idea what the book was even about.

[thefourthman]

So am I.

I take issue with him not posting for months, then swanning in picking some shitty indie book he probably doesn't even like just to be different.

He hasn't been gone for months, he's been gone for weeks.

[thefourthman]

I know it's ironic, but I just think people who don't review should be kicked out, the rules should be changed back.

The rules are pretty specific and I am pretty sure that he is within the threshholds suck.

[Punchy]

He hasn't been gone for months, he's been gone for weeks.

He's disappeared for weeks at a time 3 or 4 times now.

People have a go at Twigg for refusing to read certain weeks, but he gets a pass because he's indier-than-thou.

[Kerny]

Shield 1 (Pretty heavily spoiled)

Loved, LOVED this book

Big ideas, big Science, big fun.

The way Hickman can use classic characters and their ancestors is potentially beyond awesome. Even more so, when they interact with real life people. Including Love God Da Vinci

Leonid is our everyman character, and he has a creepy dad with a talking bird. Nuff said

My favorite part is when you see Apocalyspe and Egyptian Moon Knight ready to do battle with some Brood. Stuff like that will make the book cool. We might get some ancient symbiotes!

Weaver's art is pretty detailed, and pretty great. I got the black and white edition,so stuff really stands out. Can't wait to see where this book goes.
Hickman hasn't let me down yet.

Story 10
Art 10
Overall 10

[Punchy]

The rules are pretty specific and I am pretty sure that he is within the threshholds suck.

The rules are too lax!

IMO, if Dick wants a pick, he needs to review Blackest Night and SHIELD, but he won't, because they're DC and Marvel.

[******]

I think you should, it's not fair on others who actually do get involved.

He's been as active the past several months as anyone, just not for the past 3 weeks, which is perfectly acceptable per the OP. Stop whining.

[thefourthman]

1) That photo is about 4 years old

2) Knock off the personal attacks and stay off my Facebook

3) It's better when you're not here.

It's on Facebook its public, its not stalking. Defriend him and make your profile private.

He skirted the line on the attack.

3 is just a lie.

Sorry you don't like him, a lot of us do.

[******]

The rules are too lax!

[thefourthman]

He's disappeared for weeks at a time 3 or 4 times now.

People have a go at Twigg for refusing to read certain weeks, but he gets a pass because he's indier-than-thou.

he doesn't get a pass. He's within the threshold of the rules. He can choose to read it or not, we don't like Twigg's reasoning.

[Punchy]

It's on Facebook its public, its not stalking. Defriend him and make your profile private.

He skirted the line on the attack.

3 is just a lie.

Sorry you don't like him, a lot of us do.

He's not my friend on there I don't think.

And he's a twerp, you only like him because he's the only other person who reads Time Lincoln and other uber-indie dross