The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[Comic_Doctor]

Now that the second issues are coming out, I'm curious if any of your "Keepers" or "On The Fence" titles are moving up or down.

[Comic_Doctor]

I'm slow, but three more (in red)...

Like (will be picking up future issues)
Justice League
Batwing (will keep buying it until it lets me down)
Green Lantern
Suicide Squad
Green Arrow
Catwoman
Batman
Superboy (wasn't expecting to like this)
Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E. (another title I was surprised by)
Voodoo
Supergirl
The Flash
DC Universe Presents
Birds of Prey

On The Fence (will try another issue or two)
Detective Comics
Action Comics
Deathstroke
Mister Terrific
Stormwatch
Swamp Thing
Animal Man
Justice League International
Aquaman
The Savage Hawkman
Resurrection Man
Green Lantern Corps
Blue Beetle
Captain Atom
Red Hood and The Outlaws

OK, But Not For Me (don't plan on getting future issues)
O.M.A.C.
Men of War
Batgirl
Legion of Super-Heroes
Demon Knights
Batwoman

Dislike (DC won't be seeing me buy this again)
Hawk & Dove
Static Shock
Legion Lost
Grifter
Batman and Robin
Wonder Woman

[Arion]

I read Action Comics # 1 and I'm writing a review on it.

[Comic_Doctor]

Another one (in red)...

Like (will be picking up future issues)
Justice League
Batwing (will keep buying it until it lets me down)
Green Lantern
Suicide Squad
Green Arrow
Catwoman
Batman
Superboy (wasn't expecting to like this)
Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E. (another title I was surprised by)
Voodoo
Supergirl
The Flash
DC Universe Presents
Birds of Prey

On The Fence (will try another issue or two)
Detective Comics
Action Comics
Deathstroke
Mister Terrific
Stormwatch
Swamp Thing
Animal Man
Justice League International
Aquaman
The Savage Hawkman
Resurrection Man
Green Lantern Corps
Blue Beetle
Captain Atom
Red Hood and The Outlaws

OK, But Not For Me (don't plan on getting future issues)
O.M.A.C.
Men of War
Batgirl
Legion of Super-Heroes
Demon Knights
Batwoman
Red Lanterns

Dislike (DC won't be seeing me buy this again)
Hawk & Dove
Static Shock
Legion Lost
Grifter
Batman and Robin
Wonder Woman

[Comic_Doctor]

Dropping Green Lantern Corps after reading issue #2.

[avengingtitan]

Dropping Green Lantern Corps after reading issue #2.

Most of the #2 issues that I've read have been pretty bad. The preview for Teen Titans looks just as bad as the first issue.

[Comic_Doctor]

Four more finally read (in red)...

Like (will be picking up future issues)
Justice League
Batwing (will keep buying it until it lets me down)
Green Lantern
Suicide Squad
Green Arrow
Catwoman
Batman
Superboy (wasn't expecting to like this)
Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E. (another title I was surprised by)
Voodoo
Supergirl
The Flash
DC Universe Presents
Birds of Prey

On The Fence (will try another issue or two)
Detective Comics
Action Comics
Deathstroke
Mister Terrific
Stormwatch
Swamp Thing
Animal Man
Justice League International
Aquaman
The Savage Hawkman
Resurrection Man
Green Lantern Corps
Blue Beetle
Captain Atom
Red Hood and The Outlaws
Justice League Dark

OK, But Not For Me (don't plan on getting future issues)
O.M.A.C.
Men of War
Batgirl
Legion of Super-Heroes
Demon Knights
Batwoman
Red Lanterns
Superman

Dislike (DC won't be seeing me buy this again)
Hawk & Dove
Static Shock
Legion Lost
Grifter
Batman and Robin
Wonder Woman
Blackhawks
The Fury of Firestorm

[Amoebas]

After 3 issues, many changes in my buying habits


Monthly subscriber...
01 Legion Lost
02 OMAC
03 Wonder Woman
04 Aquaman
05 All-Star Western
06 Batman
07 I, Vampire
08 Batwoman
09 Green Lantern
10 Justice League International
11 Green Lantern Corp
12 Action
13 Batgirl
14 Batwing
15 Swamp Thing
16 Nightwing
17 Superman
18 Justice League
19 Legion of Super-Heroes
20 DCU Presents
21 Demon Knights
22 Suicide Squad

Still hooked (but barely)
23 Resurrection Man
24 Catwoman
25 Red Hood & the Outlaws
26 Supergirl
27 Birds of Prey
28 Stormwatch
28 Green Arrow

Little interest but I'll finish the first arc and decide...
29 Detective
30 New Guardians
31 Captain Atom
32 Batman & Robin
33 Voodoo
34 Men of War
36 Flash
37 Blue Beetle
38 Mister Terrific

No interest - dropped for good
39 Justice League Dark
40 Fury of Firestorm
41 Red Lanterns
42 Superboy
43 Savage Hawkman
44 Frankenstein
45 Dark Knight
46 Grifter
47 Blackhawks
48 Static
49 Teen Titans
50 Hawk & Dove
51 Deathstroke
52 Animal Man

Biggest movers since the #1's...
Men of War & Firestrom dropped way down
Green Arrow, Nightwing and especially Batwing moved up quite a bit.

[misac]

Current list:
All-Star Western
Animal Man
Batman
Batman & Robin
DCU Presents
Demon Knights
Legion Lost
Resurrection Man
Supergirl
Wonder Woman

Picked up (starting with #4):
Batman and Robin, Supergirl (luckily, I was able to find issues #2 and 3 )

Dropped:
Legion of Super Heroes and DCU Presents for the next arc.

[SilverPhoenix]

Month 4 Update

Loved it (I'm on board until the creators do something really stupid)
Animal Man

Really Liked it (Official Pull List Staples)
All Star Western
Batwoman
Wonder Woman (The Zeus thing could have long term consequences, though)
Batwing (I really hope Winick doesn't burn himself with Bruce's involvement in this book)
I, Vampire

Liked it (Books that are on the pull list or are close to getting added)
Justice League Dark (This gets a bit of a downgrade due to the Xanadu developments)
Demon Knights (Same thing)
Resurrection Man
Swamp Thing
Frankenstein: Agent of S.H.A.D.E.

On the Fence (Picking up the next couple of issues or watching closely)
Static Shock (This is only staying due to the new writer coming in 3 months)
Voodoo
Nightwing
Red Lanterns
Birds of Prey
Blue Beetle
Green Lantern: The New Guardians

Trade Wait Bait (Books that I feel will read better trade wise)
DC Comics Presents Deadman
Batman (For Scott Snyder)
Huntress
Penguin

Okay but not for me
Batgirl
Grifter
Superboy
Supergirl (Far too thinly written for my tastes)
Superman (Too old school for my tastes)
Action Comics
Stormwatch

It's probably not going to work out
Justice League International
Justice League
Batman and Robin
Green Lantern
Legion Lost (This took a huge dip once I read it again)
Legion of Superheroes
Captain Atom
O.M.A.C.
Blackhawks
Green Lantern Corps (major downgrade)
Men of War
Aquaman
Blue Beetle

You gotta be fucking kidding me
Green Arrow
Suicide Squad
Deathstroke
Detective Comics
Hawk and Dove
Catwoman (This book is more juvenile than Tarot has turned out to be lately)
Red Hood and the Outlaws (I can go on for days about how terrible this book is)
The Savage Hawkman (Tony Daniel needs to stop writing)
Teen Titans (what?)
Fury of Firestorm (There's so much wrong with this book)
Batman: The Dark Knight (David Fitch doesn't have the writing chops)
Mister Terrific (This character deserves better)

[nietoperz]

Current List

Action Comics
Batman
Batwoman
I, Vampire
Justice League
Justice League Dark
Justice League International
Legion Lost
Legion of Super-Heroes
Stormwatch
Superman
Swamp Thing

Most of these are safe, though I will be dropping Legion Lost when Fabe leaves - I've never been a fan of Tom DeFalco. Stormwatch is kind of on the fence too - I'll stick around for Paul Jenkins' arc, but if the new permanent writer isn't someone I'm into I'll drop the book. I'll also be picking up Night Force when it starts up in March.

[Arion]

Tom DeFalco will be on the Legion?

[TROY]

My current DCnU pull list:

Action Comics
Aquaman
Batman
Batman and Robin
Detective Comics
Batgirl
Nightwing
Dark Knight
Catwoman
DC Universe Presents
Deathstroke
Flash
Green Lantern
Justice League
Justice League Dark
Red Hood and the Outlaws
Suicide Squad
Superboy
Teen Titans

A few of these are on shaky ground though and may only make it one more issue before they are dropped.

[nietoperz]

Tom DeFalco will be on the Legion?

On Legion Lost, yeah.

[MoneyMelon]

I'm enjoying these:

Batman
Batman & Robin
Nightwing
Supergirl
Action Comics
All Star Western
Swamp Thing
Animal Man