The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[******]

If you were born yesterday, I could understand being surprised by the length of story, format, paperstock, pricepoint, ETC.

Just because the format was announced ahead of time doesn't mean that I can't say that it sucks. I didn't pick the book, I just posted my review of it. If it wasn't picked for the group I wouldn't have bought it because it was never something that interested me. Sorry for not following along with everyone else and loving the book.

[******]

I'm not apologizing for shit. Nope, fuck that, I will apologize to rational people in the group for letting an obviously insane and deluded man run it.

It's a requirement in the job description. Just look at my predecessors.

[vinnypic]

Just because the format was announced ahead of time doesn't mean that I can't say that it sucks. I didn't pick the book, I just posted my review of it. If it wasn't picked for the group I wouldn't have bought it because it was never something that interested me. Sorry for not following in line with everyone else and loving the book.

I don't think it's a valid criticism is all.

If you bought it knowing te format wasn't for you, then lo, the format wasn't for you, it's a cop out to use it as te basis of your criticism.

It's like saying 'ASM sucks. I hate Spider-Man and he sucks. He is the lead of ASM, terefore it sucks.'

[Victorian Squid]

Ooooooooh! Coup coup coup coup coup!

[******]

I don't think it's a valid criticism is all.

If you bought it knowing te format wasn't for you, then lo, the format wasn't for you, it's a cop out to use it as te basis of your criticism.

It's like saying 'ASM sucks. I hate Spider-Man and he sucks. He is the lead of ASM, terefore it sucks.'

The format of the series is a huge part of the experience and therefore criticizing it is fair game, IMO.

[thefourthman]

Fuck you! I refuse to accept your apology until you kick Amlah in both shins with steel-toed elf booties!

steel toed elf booties?

I can't fight will farrel.

[thefourthman]

It's a requirement in the job description. Just look at my predecessors.

I expected more from you. This day will shame you for eternity.

[******]

Ooooooooh! Coup coup coup coup coup!

[thefourthman]

The format of the series is a huge part of the experience and therefore criticizing it is fair game, IMO.

I'm not saying it isn't, but just think about this, you are agreeing with Tabu over the rest of comic dom... you might as well be yoni and darth's love child.

[vinnypic]

The format of the series is a huge part of the experience and therefore criticizing it is fair game, IMO.

Same thing as my example, IMO.

We're not about reviewing format, are we?

We're about reviewing comics. The convergance of dialogue and art.

And guess what? These stories kicked ass for the most part.

[Victorian Squid]

steel toed elf booties?

I can't fight will farrel.

C'mon, make like Crispin Glover on Letterman and KICK!

[thefourthman]

:smt015

see he can does this because I never ever want to run this group.

[Victorian Squid]

:smt015

Coup him now! He's a narcoleptic!

[******]

I expected more from you. This day will shame you for eternity.

Criticize a DC darling and the drones get their panties in a twist. It's just 52 #52 all over again.

[thefourthman]

Same thing as my example, IMO.

We're not about reviewing format, are we?

We're about reviewing comics. The convergance of dialogue and art.

And guess what? These stories kicked ass for the most part.

format is part of it, you are tettering close to Punchy territory now, just thought you might like to know.