The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[doombug]

Since you refuse to read the book, I vote you don't get a pick :p

I vote you go back to selling yourself on your damn corner and leave my choice to me.

[S.F. Jude Terror]

Since you refuse to read the book, I vote you don't get a pick :p

I am not only going to rate Doombug's pick a 0.0 in response to him not reading this book and giving it a fair shot, but I am also going to deduct 5 points from any book featuring Deadpool from here on out in retaliation.

[S.F. Jude Terror]

Same goes for Punchy, anything that Bendis got anywhere near is getting 5 points deducted from its overall score from me from now on.

[thefourthman]

I vote you go back to selling yourself on your damn corner and leave my choice to me.

I would gladly sell myself, unfortunately, no one is buying. Do you think it is the odor or the economy?

[thefourthman]

So what are you gonna deduct points from me from?

[******]

I'm not going to even lie on this one. It's a toss up between a vertigo book or a dc book and they are both #1's.

Thank you for ruling out Tales of the Deadpool Corps.

/everybody'd

[Punchy]

Same goes for Punchy, anything that Bendis got anywhere near is getting 5 points deducted from its overall score from me from now on.

I never said I won't review it, I just don't want to.

It's not good to write negative reviews, it's too easy to just bash something, I like to be more constructive, but in this case... can I even do that?

[S.F. Jude Terror]

So what are you gonna deduct points from me from?

You gave the book what I feel was a relatively fair shot, since you posted in tiny text underneath how much you liked it.

[doombug]

I am not only going to rate Doombug's pick a 0.0 in response to him not reading this book and giving it a fair shot, but I am also going to deduct 5 points from any book featuring Deadpool from here on out in retaliation.

I'd rather not read the book and give it a shot at a better score (because once again after reading that preview I really want nothing to do with it) then add to the scores and have it at a lower score.

Because unlike Punchy who last I read last week said he was going to give it a bad score, I'd rather stay away and give it the chance it deserves at a decent score.

Not to mention I know for a fact my shop wont have it because they only have copies of Forever for subscribers.

[S.F. Jude Terror]

I never said I won't review it, I just don't want to.

It's not good to write negative reviews, it's too easy to just bash something, I like to be more constructive, but in this case... can I even do that?

I don't see why you would have such a negative opinion of it without having read it. Seems silly.

[doombug]

I would gladly sell myself, unfortunately, no one is buying. Do you think it is the odor or the economy?

It's the hair.

[Punchy]

I don't see why you would have such a negative opinion of it without having read it. Seems silly.

I don't read it to know I won't like it, same reason I haven't seen Meet The Spartans, but still say it's shit.

[S.F. Jude Terror]

I'd rather not read the book and give it a shot at a better score (because once again after reading that preview I really want nothing to do with it) then add to the scores and have it at a lower score.

Because unlike Punchy who last I read last week said he was going to give it a bad score, I'd rather stay away and give it the chance it deserves at a decent score.

Not to mention I know for a fact my shop wont have it because they only have copies of Forever for subscribers.

I'm going to pick a Deadpool book on my next turn just so I can give it a low rating.

[doombug]

Thank you for ruling out Tales of the Deadpool Corps.

/everybody'd

I'm reading it but I wont make you guys suffer through that art.

[thefourthman]

I don't read it to know I won't like it, same reason I haven't seen Meet The Spartans, but still say it's shit.

Itt: Punchy not only hates Jude's favorite comic sight unseen, but his favorite movie as well.