The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[Eli Katz]

If Jean Grey isn't shown to be getting anal from Logan doggystyle while Cyclops sits in the corner crying and masturbating, gets another zero from me.

What do cyclops' tears look like? Wet laser beams?

[Victorian Squid]

What do cyclops' tears look like? Wet laser beams?

Better pass him some ruby-quartz Kleenex.

[doombug]

Why bother to review it though? Jude will just be all butt hurt that no one likes it even when we give it an average score.


Seriously if this was good Chris Claremont, I'd give a damn. But nope, rather read that firestar book. (which I will be)

Guess my names going in the red.

[Punchy]

Fucking hell.

[thefourthman]

Why bother to review it though? Jude will just be all butt hurt that no one likes it even when we give it an average score.


Seriously if this was good Chris Claremont, I'd give a damn. But nope, rather read that firestar book. (which I will be)

Guess my names going in the red.

sorry, done with verse...l
cause it is a group and we are supposed to be giving books the benefit of the doubt, not only that being critical on at least some level of an objective manner. This one has a good artist, so I am hoping that makes a difference.

I would rather that if people aren't going to review it through obstinance that they just keep mum about why. That would prevent a lot of butt hurt, until Punchy demands that you be kicked out of the fucking group. This week fucking HOJ, Amlah and I went out of our way to give more people an opportunity to review this book and no one cared. That sucks in my opinion.

[******]

I'm excited for next week, I want to give XMF another chance. It helps that the preview art looks a lot better this time around.

[doombug]

sorry, done with verse...l
cause it is a group and we are supposed to be giving books the benefit of the doubt, not only that being critical on at least some level of an objective manner. This one has a good artist, so I am hoping that makes a difference.

I would rather that if people aren't going to review it through obstinance that they just keep mum about why. That would prevent a lot of butt hurt, until Punchy demands that you be kicked out of the fucking group. This week fucking HOJ, Amlah and I went out of our way to give more people an opportunity to review this book and no one cared. That sucks in my opinion.

i wanted to read this weeks, thought i had it on my pull and obviously i didn't.

and like i said, i'll just be reading the thread next week but forcing x-men forever on people again after it was his last pick....change it up jude.

just not in a great mood right now. Plus even if I asked you for a copy it wouldn't get here until next week and it wouldn't add to the over all score at all. I like doing stuff on the actual week in question.

[thefourthman]

i wanted to read this weeks, thought i had it on my pull and obviously i didn't.

and like i said, i'll just be reading the thread next week but forcing x-men forever on people again after it was his last pick....change it up jude.

just not in a great mood right now. Plus even if I asked you for a copy it wouldn't get here until next week and it wouldn't add to the over all score at all. I like doing stuff on the actual week in question.

it adds to the sod, and dammit, we said this shit on Tuesday.

[doombug]

I was just hoping that for once Jude wouldn't do what you guys were predicting.

Punchy will give it a low score, I wont buy it and we know whenever old man returns he'll lower the core too.

I mean I hate to sound like an asshole but how does he think this will be any different then about a month back.

[Victorian Squid]

I'm excited for next week, I want to give XMF another chance. It helps that the preview art looks a lot better this time around.

The art looks SO much better.\

My last zero was a joke relating to Jude banning Fourthy, I meant to change it back.

[******]

Hey Starlord, what the fuck is up with Old Man?! Tell him to get his geriatric ass back here.

[******]

i wanted to read this weeks, thought i had it on my pull and obviously i didn't.

and like i said, i'll just be reading the thread next week but forcing x-men forever on people again after it was his last pick....change it up jude.

just not in a great mood right now. Plus even if I asked you for a copy it wouldn't get here until next week and it wouldn't add to the over all score at all. I like doing stuff on the actual week in question.

Who doesn't? Shit happens sometimes, you know? Get over it and PM 4thy for this weeks book and post a review when you can.

[thefourthman]

The art looks SO much better.\

My last zero was a joke relating to Jude banning Fourthy, I meant to change it back.

I got banned? I don't remember this.

[Victorian Squid]

I got banned? I don't remember this.

I think that was during your brief tenure as Broken Frontier Forum Czar. He said he banned you for your low XMF score, I figured I wanted to get banned too, so I lowered my score to a 0. But I meant to change it back, I just forgot.

Man, you sure got those forums going though!

[Victorian Squid]

Lee, you read Doc Savage #1 last week? I ain't gonna lie, I intended to give it a try but it just didn't read that well when I skimmed it.

Plus, so much beefcake