The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

by **MoneyMelon** » Wed Dec 26, 2007 10:13 pm

Thought this might be fun.

And I'm keeping it simple.

I'll post my picks later.

Here's the categories:

1. Best character
2. Best DC book
3. Best Marvel book
4. Best Indy book
5. Best writer
6. Best artist
7. Best mini-series
8. Best single issue
9. Best villain
10. Best new series

by **L Independant** » Wed Dec 26, 2007 10:42 pm

Are you going to aggregate these? I recommend against it, as it was a CHORE last year.

1. Best character - Batman
2. Best DC book - All Star Superman
3. Best Marvel book - I dunno, I don't like Marvel
4. Best Indy book - I can't remember
5. Best writer - (tie) Grant Morrison and BKV
6. Best artist - I dunno
7. Best mini-series - Dunno
8. Best single issue - Dunno
9. Best villain - Dunno
10. Best new series - Dunno. Nothing that'd keep me reading comics, I guess.

by **Zenguru** » Wed Dec 26, 2007 11:23 pm

MoneyMelon wrote:Thought this might be fun.

And I'm keeping it simple.

I'll post my picks later.

Here's the categories:

1. Best character
2. Best DC book
3. Best Marvel book
4. Best Indy book
5. Best writer
6. Best artist
7. Best mini-series
8. Best single issue
9. Best villain
10. Best new series

1. Booster Gold
2. Green Lantern
3. Thor
4. Not much of a indy reader these days
5. Geoff Johns
6. Ivan Reis
7. Sinestro Corps
8. Green Lantern #25
9. Superman Prime
10. Booster Gold

by **BigBatFan** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 1:03 am

1. Best character-Batman
2. Best DC book - The last two issues of Action puts it on top.
3. Best Marvel book-Blade

(and they still publish Black Panther? WTF?!?)
4. Best Indy book I just read Blankets, so I'll vote that. or did Astro City Dark Age II
come out this year?
5. Best writer- Marc Guggenhiem
6. Best artist- Marko Durjivic
7. Best mini-series (or Graphic novel) Silverfish
8. Best single issue Superman #667, That issue had everything, best penultimate chapter ever! The finale was ok.
9. Best villain -Joe Q
10. Best new series The Programme.

11. Best Cover.

Spidey never looked so good. And I want a Punisher/Micky T-Shirt.

by **john lewis hawk** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 2:29 am

1. Best character- Iron Man
2. Best DC book- The Spirit
3. Best Marvel book- Captain America
4. Best Indy book- Casanova
5. Best writer- Ed Brubaker
6. Best artist- Darwyn Cooke
7. Best mini-series- The Other Side
8. Best single issue- The Spirit #9 (El Muerto's debut)
9. Best villain-
10. Best new series- Immortal Iron Fist

by **DeadFett** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 2:39 am

1. Best character - DeadPool
2. Best DC book - Green Lantern
3. Best Marvel book - Captain America
4. Best Indy book - Star Wars: Legacy
5. Best writer - Ed Brubaker
6. Best artist - Jim Lee
7. Best mini-series - X-Men: Endangered Species
8. Best single issue - Captain America #25
9. Best villain - Sinestro
10. Best new series - Immortal Iron Fist

by **nietoperz** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 2:55 am

1. Batman

2. Booster Gold

3. n/a

4. Buffy The Vampire Slayer

5. Grant Morrison

6. George Perez

7. 52

8. Booster Gold #1

9. Joe Quesada

10. Booster Gold

by **Severed Djed** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 10:55 am

1. Best character - Batman
2. Best DC book - Justice Society of America
3. Best Marvel book - Immortal Iron Fist
4. Best Indy book - Did Phonogram come out this year?
5. Best writer - Grant Morrison
6. Best artist - Ivan Reis
7. Best mini-series - It's not over yet, but I'll still say Umbrella Academy
8. Best single issue - Green Lantern #25
9. Best villain - Sinestro
10. Best new series - Booster Gold

by **MoneyMelon** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 10:59 am

1. Best character- Winter Soldier/Bucky
2. Best DC book- Green Lantern
3. Best Marvel book- Captain America
4. Best Indy book- The Boys
5. Best writer- Geoff Johns
6. Best artist- George Perez
7. Best mini-series- Omega Flight
8. Best single issue- Green lantern #25
9. Best villain- Sinestro
10. Best new series- Batman and the Outsiders
[/b]

by **kingbobb** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 12:52 pm

1. Best character: Batman
2. Best DC book: Brave and the Bold
3. Best Marvel book: Captain America
4. Best Indy book: Walking Dead
5. Best writer: Peter David
6. Best artist: George Perez
7. Best mini-series:
8. Best single issue: Civil War #1
9. Best villain: Iron Man
10. Best new series: Buffy: Season 8

by **Jonathan** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 2:14 pm

1. Best character
2. Best DC book
3. Best Marvel book
4. Best Indy book
5. Best writer
6. Best artist
7. Best mini-series
8. Best single issue
9. Best villain
10. Best new series - New Warriors (Marvel)

.....man.....I got NOTHIN'. :shock:

by **Zero** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 2:21 pm

1. Best character - Bucky
2. Best DC book - Y The Last Man
3. Best Marvel book - Captain America
4. Best Indy book - Scott Pilgrim vol. 4
5. Best writer - Ed Brubaker
6. Best artist - Ben Templesmith
7. Best mini-series - Pirates of Coney Island
8. Best single issue - Captain America #25
9. Best villain - Bullseye
10. Best new series - Scalped was this year? Scalped is great

by **3MJ** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 2:24 pm

1. Best character: Nova
2. Best DC book: ASS
3. Best Marvel book: New Avengers
4. Best Indy book: Invincible
5. Best writer: Warren Ellis
6. Best artist: That one whose name I can't spell Djecuvic or whatever
7. Best mini-series: New Avengers: Illuminati
8. Best single issue: The New Avengers issue with Hawkeye finding Scarlet Witch, my God I loved that art
9. Best villain: Ultron
10. Best new series: Immortal Iron Fist

by **misac** » Thu Dec 27, 2007 3:00 pm

1. Best character – Winter Soldier
2. Best DC book - 52
3. Best Marvel book – Captain America
4. Best Indy book – Mice Templar
5. Best writer – Ed Brubaker
6. Best artist – Rod Garney
7. Best mini-series – 52
8. Best single issue – Immortal Iron Fist #7
9. Best villain – Iron Man
10. Best new series – The Order

EDIT: I changed my mini series vote.