*Membership spots not really limited!
I little to dirty but I luv it!
Not dirty at all. I like it.
*Membership spots not really limited!
achilles wrote:I thought Power Girl #15 was an excellent issue of the series. Winick is doing far more with Kara and her supporting cast in his what 3 issues so far than Palmiotti and Gray did in their 12. Which isn't to say P and G were bad, just that they favored a rather static form of storytelling that didn't really effect the characters, grow them, or change them---at all.
OTOH, Winick gives us the first one of PG's supporting cast I can distinguish from the others apart from Terra of course. And he shows us just how tough and resilient Kara is, and how she can direct a battle, thinking through things rather than just hitting. I get Herald, he's just reflexively anti-DC most days, and really, really hates Winick. But the one or two others who share his view on this issue I don't get.
Sure, there are a couple of minor quibbles, like the Kryptonite thing, which may or may not be Winick forgetting she's immune, (though someone pointed out it might also be Max making her think it was hurting her), or the lack of her putting Crash in the middle of the Atlantic, (which upon actually reading it seemed like it was something that would be a lot easier said than done with a Doomsday level guy---recall that Superman tried to get Doomsday into space and couldn't). But on the whole, this issue advanced Kara's story, presented her as not only a mega powerful hero, but one who had guts and brains to go with it, as well as a certain toughness and willingness to do a few not terribly nice things to win.
How the latter plays out with Nikko remains to be seen, though we seem sure to get him as a continuing character and sidekick to PG from comments elsewhere. Though he is one of many hacker type sidekicks in the DCU these days, he works in context of who PG is and what she's doing, and seems an interesting character in his own right.
And while taking the focus away from Terra takes away all of that relationship stuff that was nice and fun, it also allows more focus on Power Girl herself, and on developing her as a hero.
Perhaps not the best issue of the series, but certainly one of them on the whole. It did what it needed to do and moved the title character and the series along, setting up some good stuff for later issues.
Arion wrote:I haven't read a PG story in ages .
Duck Punch wrote:
I agree with you on a lot of this. I thought the endings, both of the fight and the last page itself, were stellar. I'm really excited that this book is being worked back into the larger DC universe, as opposed to just sitting off in its own corner. Not that there's anything wrong with putting in its own sandbox, but having Power Girl interact with Brightest Day opens whole new possibilities for this book.
I'm also thrilled that she's actually getting her own honest-to-goodness cast of characters to work with. Has that ever really been something this character has ever had, outside of Terra?
She had a 'Lois Lane' character of her own back on Earth-Two whose name I can't recall off hand, but mostly her interactions were with other heroes.
You're not missing anything in Winick's run. Just the usual Winick misery.
Dragavon wrote:He's being diplomatic again.
Zechs wrote:I have to repress you more. You're way too goodie two shoes.
Fat Ollie Weeks wrote:I swear to God, you are so boring sometimes I think you're just a stealth-mod-bot that Jude has coded.
Herald wrote:You're not missing anything in Winick's run. Just the usual Winick misery.
Victorian Squid wrote:In a DC/Marvel cross-over "all your favorite Marvel characters would catch contextually-transmitted diseases and Steph infections."
Winick is doing a good job on PG, sure it is not the same goofy fun level that Gray and Palimioti but I think what has been done so far has been a nice addition to the character.
Users browsing this forum: Yahoo [Bot] and 61 guests