The Outhouse - The Greatest Comic Book Forum

[Jubilee]

I liked this list results more than I've ever liked any other.

[Zab]

And yeah, thanks for doing this guys, appreciate the effort.

[Stephen Day]

I think top story is easier for me to narrow down than top run was.

I think its going to be even harder for me. I can't see Crisis on Infinite Earths, Under Siege from Avengers, The Trigon saga from the Wolfman Perez Teen Titans, Cosmos in Collision from Quasar and Mark Gruenwald's masterpiece known as Captain America No More not making my list. That's going to leave five slots to represent the rest of my history as a reader and my views of comic book history.

Its not going to be an easy task.

[Stephen Day]

Throw on top of that the fact that every limited series I've ever read will be eligible, something I didn't have to think about with the Top Runs list.

[chap22]

I think top story is easier for me to narrow down than top run was.

my early favorites:

Kraven's Last Hunt
Born Again
Judas Contract
Batman Year One
Cap vs. Red Skull (Cap 290 - 301)
Under Siege
Return of Barry Allen
New Frontier
Grand Guignol
God Loves, Man Kills

i threw out single issue stories just because. once i did that, those 10 above are the stories i re-read the most.

after those, i'd also probably have to consider:

Fantastic Four vs. X-Men (Claremont/Bogdanove mini)
Golden Age
Heaven's Ladder
The Nail
Gotham by Gaslight
ASS vs. Ultra-Humanite and debut of Infinity Inc. (All-Star Squadron 21 - 25 and Annual 2)
Shang-Chi vs. Fu Manchu (MoKF 44-51 primarily, but really everything from the first Gulacy issue onward led up to that)
Dark Phoenix Saga
The Night Gwen Stacy Died
Time, Like A Runaway Freight Train...
JMD's Harry Saga
Armor Wars
Cap No More (332-350)
Blackfire/X'Hal/Citadel "War!" arc
Lost in Space-Time
Ultron Unlimited
Galactus Saga
Battle for the Baxter Building
COIE
Elektra Saga
Man Without Fear
Nocenti's arc with DD vs. Mephisto
Guardian Devil
Quiver


shit...maybe this is harder than i thought...

[Jubilee]

Chap I'm counting on you for coming through on that thing I PM'ed you about the other day.

My top ten stories would be kick ass.

[Stalzer2002]

Top Stories...hmm....

Avengers Under Siege
X-Men Dark Phoenix
X-Men Days of Future Past
Spider-Man: Nothing Stops the Juggernaut
Spider-Man: Kraven's Last Hunt
Daredevil: Born Again
Immortal Iron Fist: Happy Birthday Danny
Batman: Year One
Batman: The Dark Knight Returns
Green Lantern: Emerald Twilight
Golden Age
Watchmen
Scalped: Gravel in your Gut
Astro City: Confessions

[False Prophet]

I'd be curious to see where 90s stories like AoA, Reign of the Supermen, and Emerald Twilight rank.

[Jubilee]

I really dislike AOA.

[BubbaKanoosh]

I'd be curious to see where 90s stories like AoA, Reign of the Supermen, and Emerald Twilight rank.

maximum clonage.

Heh

[False Prophet]

I really dislike AOA.

Seriously? I'd have thought you'd like it. It definitely had a '00s Marvel flavor to it.

[False Prophet]

maximum clonage.

Heh

Keep that shit to yourself.









But Ben Reilly does rule, and fuck anyone who says otherwise.

[BubbaKanoosh]

I really dislike AOA.

I enjoyed it.

Then again, I'm a fan if elseworld and what if type stuff.

Alt. Universes stories I always buy. Always.

[BubbaKanoosh]

But Ben Reilly does rule, and fuck anyone who says otherwise.

fact

[capjr]

I enjoyed it.

Then again, I'm a fan if elseworld and what if type stuff.

Alt. Universes stories I always buy. Always.

How do you feel about the Earth X stuff?