First let me get the good out of the way, there isn't much of it so this won't take long. The best thing about 4e is combat. It is very smooth and streamlined, and all attacks and movement actions fall into Free, Minor, Standard, and Full Round actions. All special attacks, powers, spells, and what not are broken up into At-Will, Encounter, and Daily uses. Spells and powers and attacks are all treated exactly the same way, so this really tends to speed up and streamline combat. Being able to use acrobatics to get away with crazy stuff, and the game encouraging GM's to allow it rather than stifle it is also a nice touch. And that is the end of the good things about 4e.
The problem with all that is that all the powers, spells, and special attacks not only work the same way, but they feel the same too. I am sure those of you who have an ear to the Gaming world have heard the 4E/MMORPG comparisons, and the similarity is obvious when using the new combat mechanics. The Warlocks magical abilities feel and function exactly the same as the Rogues Attacks. It all feels very cookie cutter, and very formulaic. Almost sterile. While there is room for customization, it is minor, and depending on role and race chosen, everyone’s is pretty much going to pick the same powers regardless of the other options. Of course the D20 system went overboard with customization, to the point where generating a first level character could take hours just to figure out the feats. 4E takes that to the other extreme, where you choices are actually pretty limited, but they fool you into thinking there are more than are actually available by offering powers no one would actually take.
It's not as confined as say, Basic or AD&D, but both of those versions were still more entertaining to me, even with my legendary hatred of THACO.
To further worsen matters, non-combat encounters
and trials are no longer handled through creative role-play or skill
use. Instead they are handled through "Skill Challenges" which
basically consist of the entire party making various rolls, and the
number of successes or failures determines the outcome. On the surface
it doesn't seem like a bad idea, but in reality this mechanic actually
discourages role-play. So now playing Dungeons and Dragons feels even
more like playing Everquest, Worlds of Warcraft, or whatnot by
eschewing role-playing altogether and just moving from combat to
combat, collecting loot and XP, and every now and then rolling some
dice to get to the next combat. It is the antithesis of everything I
play RPG's for.
It didn't really dawn on my until a friend who was a new to tabletop gaming but an old pro at Everquest decided, after only a few months of sporadic 4e, to run an Everquest world based game of his own. The first session was just spent running around outside Freeport collecting rat pelts and Orc Skins... And it honestly felt exactly like playing EQ. To the point that I was bored of it after 20 minutes and went off and clipped my toenails.
4E, even in the standard setting is just like
that. Even the treasure is generic and sterile. The longest lasting
spells only last until the end of an encounter, which means no more
casting invisibility and wandering about exploring, no more casting fly
just for the heck of it, pretty much no more of anything that doesn't
involve beating down something.
It's the only system I have ever played that
actively discourages role-playing. After 6 months of playing now, I can
count on one hand the number of conversations with NPC's that lasted
longer than GM narration and basic response. And the group I play with
are experienced role-players, who are in other games known for spending
entire sessions on conversations and planning.
Gaming it seems has come full circle. In the
beginning, video games did everything they could to emulate Dungeons
and Dragons. Turn based combat, hit points, Stats, how Spells were cast
and their effects, were all the designers very best efforts to bring
Tarp’s to consoles and computers. Now 4e is trying to emulate the
games, and succeeding entirely too well.
Don't get me wrong, I love combat, an RPG
without fighting is like and RPG without dice... best left to
pretentious wankers who are as easily placated by wearing their mothers
underwear. But combat without accompanying storyline, without plot upon
which to build my characters personality and personal history, is not
something that appeals to me in an RPG. Epic Battles without the drama
leading up to them are as exciting and anti-climactic as prematurely
ejaculating while touching yourself.
I have played a lot of systems over the years, I have written my own, and I can say without doubt, that 4e is the least challenging game, in terms of creativity and storytelling, that I have ever played. Yet I continue playing, because despite my protests, and these obvious revelations, it's Dungeons and Dragons, and that’s what my group wants to play most of the time.
So in summary, if you really love MMORPG’s, and want a TRPG that emulates them perfectly, 4E is definitely your cup of tea. But if you are someone that like to mix story and you know, role-playing in with the combat, then I can’t really recommend it.
On the brighter side, Interlock Unlimited is
going extremely well. I just updated the Super Hero rules and added
art, and Psionics rules are out and both are working extremely well.
Also added a rules add-on for vehicular combat and civilian land
vehicle construction (Military, aircraft, and Power armor construction
rules are in the Cyberpunk 2020 book Maximum Metal, Spacecraft and
Mecha rules are in the books Mekton Z and Roadstrykers II for Mekton
both by R. Talsorian Games. The only rules add-ons really necessary for
me to do now are Magic, though I would like to see a set of Watercraft
Rules as well. After those are out of the way, I can get down to the
gritty of setting specific flavor, like bestiaries, aliens, and fantasy
race compendiums…. Yay….
The Core rules just got another update as well,
clearing a few minor things up, and Interlock Unlimited now has it's
own forum, since discussion and development got too big for a yahoo
Finished Interlock Unlimited products can be found on my site Datafortress 2020 here:
And for the latest projects in development and active discussion you can visit the Interlock Unlimited forums here:
Go here to discuss.
The Outhouse is sponsored this week by Late Nite Draw. Recently featured on ComicsAlliances' Best Art Ever, he is a Chicago-based commissioned artist with a self-published Digital+Print one-shot coming out in October about the abominable snowman called ABOBAMANIMABBLE, and is also available for commissions. Check out some amazing art by clicking here or by clicking the banner at the top, and support the people who support The Outhouse.
Comment without an Outhouse Account using Facebook
Note: while you are welcome to speak your mind freely on any topic, we do ask that you keep discussion civil between each other. Nasty personal attacks against other commenters is strongly discouraged. Thanks!