Royal Nonesuch takes a look at the latest volume of Boom! Studios' Eureka, based on Syfy's hit original series.
EUREKA VOL. 2: DORMANT GENE
Written by Andrew Cosby, Jaime Paglia, Jonathan L. Davis
Drawn by Mark Dos Santos
SC, 112 pgs, FC, SRP: $16.99
Sci-Fi Channel’s smash hit show returns in this new trade compiling all the issues of the critically acclaimed, fan-favorite series masterminded by the creators of the show and told completely in continuity! EUREKA creators Andrew Cosby and Jaime Paglia are joined by writer Jonathan L. Davis (THE DUKES OF HAZZARD) with a story centering on the kids of Eureka High. Can Zoe find out why all her classmates are going goth? Read this volume and find out.
Adaptations and licensed material have a tough task ahead of them: appeal to the pre-existing fans of the property while doing the same for those who have no familiarity with it. This contrary nature can often lead to a comic book falling short creatively. Many of these types of comics try to serve two masters, but only end up failing both.
Not only can the second volume of Boom!'s Eureka be read without having seen the television show it's based on, it can be enjoyed without even having read the first volume. The world of Eureka is pleasantly established within the first few pages via the narrative itself in a most unobtrusive way. Once that's out of the way, the story is a quick, breezy read that's charmingly engaging and filled with clever dialogue and cultural references. The premise of a regular, everyday father and daughter taking up residence in a town filled entirely with super scientists is wonderful, and is presented here in a compelling way.
The problems inherent in a licensed property do show up in the art. Mark Dos Santos does a great job in terms of storytelling and overall flow, but the problem is in the figure work. Although very competent, the art here is striving for likenesses, since these characters were all created for the screen. As a result, they tend to come off stiff and lifeless in certain spots. There are several individual panels arrayed throughout the book where characters are not interacting with their environments naturally. That's not to say that the art is completely photorealistic--dos Santos is a far cry from Greg Land, after all. His art trends more toward the cartoony expressiveness of Amanda Conner than anything else (and the colors by Digikore Studios recall Laura Allred). If anything, the need to achieve this resemblance to actors hinders the artist, who could do great work if he could cut loose a little bit. In fact, the art in the book is at its best when dos Santos is free to simply illustrate. It must be tough to negotiate the necessities of licensing.
Overall, Eureka vol. 2: Dormant Gene is a light, but fun read. It's structured well enough for Eureka non-fans, and according to the press materials, it takes place within the continuity of the show, so hopefully fans can enjoy this as well. It also works well for older and younger readers alike.
7.5 of 10
Comment without an Outhouse Account using Facebook
Note: while you are welcome to speak your mind freely on any topic, we do ask that you keep discussion civil between each other. Nasty personal attacks against other commenters are not welcome here. Thanks!